Florida Balm

Get Key Lime Pie Delivered!

Send a Key Lime Pie to Yourself or as a Delicious Gift!

Key lime pie, with its perfect balance of sweet and tart, is a dessert that can truly tantalize the taste buds. But what if you’re craving a slice and don’t have the time (or energy) to bake one yourself? Or perhaps you’d like to send a delightful surprise to a friend or loved one? 

The good news is that you can now have delicious key lime pie delivered straight to your door, or shipped as a gift to someone special.

This blog post is your one-stop guide to getting your key lime pie fix, delivered fresh!

Delivering key lime pie

How Do Key Lime Pie Companies Package and Ship Their Pies?

Since key lime pie is a delicate dessert, shipping companies take special precautions to ensure it arrives fresh and intact. Here’s what you can generally expect:

  • Freezing: Most companies freeze their pies before shipping. This extends shelf life and helps the pie maintain its structure during transport.
  • Packaging: Pies are typically wrapped securely in plastic wrap or freezer paper to prevent leaks and freezer burn. They may then be placed in a cardboard box with additional cushioning materials like packing peanuts or shredded paper.
  • Insulated Boxes: Many companies utilize insulated boxes with ice packs or gel packs to maintain a cold temperature during shipping, especially for longer distances.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.

Additional Tips:

  • Be sure to check the specific shipping information of the company you choose. Some companies may offer different shipping options, such as expedited shipping with guaranteed arrival times.
  • During warmer months, some companies may offer limited availability on shipped pies due to temperature concerns.
By understanding how key lime pie companies prepare their products for shipping, you can feel confident that your pie will arrive fresh and ready to enjoy!

Key Lime Pie Companies Who Ship

Several companies specialize in shipping delectable key lime pies nationwide. Here are a few highly-rated options to get you started:
  • Key Lime Pie Co.: This company, located in Key West, Florida, prides itself on using the finest natural ingredients in their award-winning key lime pies. They offer traditional and gluten-free options, with overnight shipping available. Official website: Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

  • Southern Baked Pie Company: These pies are highly rated and have an expansive list of pies that they ship, including a delicious key lime pie. Official website: Southern Baked Pie Company

Other Popular Key Lime Pie Makers (who don't ship)

  • Fireman Derek’s Bakery: This store has two locations in Miami and one in Ft. Lauderdale, and offers an award-winning key lime pie that is known for a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors. They don’t ship, but are worth the visit when you’re in South Florida.

  • Blonde Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory: This popular bakery is located in Islamorada (The Florida Keys) and has delicious handcrafted slices and whole pies for sale. 

How Long Do Key Lime Pies Last?

The shelf life of a key lime pie depends on whether it’s frozen or refrigerated. Here’s a quick guide:
  • Unopened, Frozen Pie: Can last up to a year at 0°F (-18°C)
  • Opened, Frozen Pie: Can last up to 3 months at  0°F (-18°C)
  • Refrigerated Pie: Should be consumed within 3-5 days

Can Dogs Eat Key Lime?

Scenario: Your key lime pie delivery is sitting on the kitchen counter. Your dog is naturally very curious… and decides to lick it. And then lick more. And more because… well… it’s key lime pie and it tastes delicious! But is it bad for them? What might happen? 

NO your dog should NOT eat key lime pie. So make sure not to leave it out where your dog may be able to eat it! The pie will be difficult from them to digest, and the ingredients include dairy which can cause stomach upset.